The perils of presidentialism: Post-Soviet Politics Arguments for Linz’s Hypothesis.

  • Oleg I. Zaznaev Kazan Federal University
  • Viktor V. Sidorov. Kazan Federal University
Keywords: parliamentarism, presidentialism, post-Soviet policy, color revolutions, Linz hypothesis

Abstract

The hypothesis of the well-known political scientist Juan Linz about the shortcomings of the presidential system of government is confirmed in post-Soviet politics. Here, the states with strong presidents demonstrate tendencies of personality regime development. The political crises in such regimes often end with revolutions, society is subject to deep breaks, and regimes lose temporary flexibility. The impossibility of a quick change of the president who lost legitimacy leads to the loss of the entire system stability. They confirmed Linz’s assertion about the possibility of conflict between the president and the parliament, as well as the president’s desire for an inefficient spending. The empirical analysis of political processes in the post-Soviet space proves the validity of the hypothesis by Linz.

References

H. Aliyev. 2016. End to informality? Examining the impact of institutional reforms on informal institutions in post-Euromaidan Ukraine; Debatte, vol. 24, № 3, pp. 207-221.

M. Beissinger. 2015. Structure and example in modular political phenomena: The diffusion of bulldozer/rose/orange/tulip revolutions”, Perspectives on Politics, vol. 5, № 2, pp. 259-276.

S. Bolukbasi. 2013. Azerbaijan: A Political History, p.312.

A. Brown. 1993. The October crisis of 1993: Context and implications; Post-Soviet Affairs, vol. 9, № 3, pp. 183-195,

E. Finkel, Y. Brudny. 2014. Coloured Revolutions and Authoritarian Reactions, Routledge, 152 p.

V. Gorokhov. 2015. Forward Russia! Sports mega-events as a venue for building national identity; Nationalities Papers, vol. 43, № 2, pp. 267-282.

I. Khmelko, Y. Pereguda, Y. 2014. An Anatomy of Mass Protests: The Orange Revolution and Euromaydan Compared; Communist and Post-Communist Studies, vol. 47, № 2.

J. Linz. 1990. The Perils of Presidentialism; Journal of Democracy, vol. 1, № 1, pp. 51-69.

L. March. 2009. Managing opposition in a hybrid regime: Just Russia and parastatal opposition; Slavic Review, vol. 68, № 3, pp. 504-547.

M. Müller. (2014). After Sochi 2014: Costs and impacts of Russia’s Olympic Games Eurasian; Geography and Economics, vol. 55, № 6, pp. 628-655.

Published
2018-12-01