Criteria of justice of punishment and its individualization.

  • Karina A. Ainoutdinova Kazan Federal University, Faculty of Law, Criminal Law Department
  • Alexandra Yu. Bokovnya Kazan Federal University, Faculty of Law, Criminal Law Department
  • Fedor R. Sundurov. Kazan Federal University, Faculty of Law, Criminal law Department
Keywords: nature and degree of public danger, the identity of the perpetrator, differentiation and individualization of punishment, criteria for individualization of punishment, purpose of punishment

Abstract

This article analyzes criteria of justice and individualization of punishment and highlights that the ideas of humanization of criminal punishment are increasingly recognized and predetermines the need to reform the criminal law in the context of the consistent implementation of the proportionality requirement of a crime and the punishment, assuring their impartiality and convenience. The authors perform a comparative analysis of the criteria of impartiality and individualization, and indicate their non-coincidence. In his opinion, the individualization of punishment determines and implements only one aspect of the justice of punishment, determining that the criminal legislation of the Russian Federation has a certain bias in the individualization of punishment in the direction of its mitigation.

References

Ashworth A. Principles of Criminal Law. 4th ed. Oxford, 2003. P.19.

Criminal Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. http://law.edu.ru/norm/norm.asp?normID=1242643&subID=100101635,100101636#text http://www.cnaa.md/en/thesis/16124/

Dine J., Gobert J. (2000). Cases and Materials on Criminal Law. 3ed ed. L., P.29.

Naumov A.V. (2016). Russian criminal law: a course of lectures: in 3 volumes. V. 1: General part / A.V. Naumov. - M.: Federal Chamber of Lawyers of the Russian Federation, p. 60.

Osadcii Cornel (2004). Differentiation and individualization of the penalty of imprisonment, (deprivation Article-by-article comment on the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation / Ed. A.I. Chuchaev. - M.: Infra-M: Kontrakt, p. 10.

Pradel J. (1996). Droit penal. 11e ed. Tom 1. Introduction generale. Droit penal general. p.20.

Stephen J.F. (1883). A History of the Criminal Law of England. In Three Volumes Vol. I. L., P.81.

F.R. Sundurov, I.A. Tarkhanov (2016). Criminal law. General part: Textbook / Ed. 2nd ed., revised. - M.: Statut, p. 592.

The Criminal Code of Austria. – http://crimpravo.ru/page/zar-uk

The Criminal Code of Switzerland. – http://law.edu.ru/norm/norm.asp?normID=1241950

Published
2018-12-01